Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Madeleine Leininger Transcultural Nursing Theory Meaning
One of the most widely recognized nursing theories is the Transcultural Nursing Care Theory. The researcher, who coined the idea, is believed to be the draftswoman of nursing cultural theory. Since she began her writings in the 1960s, Madeleine has become one of the influential researchers in the field of transcultural nursing. The theory attempts to provide culturally compatible nursing care while using acts that are supportive and facilitative. Moreover, it suggests tailor-made decisions that fit within institutional, group or individuals’ lifeways, cultural values, and beliefs. The main purpose of Leininger’s care is to have beneficial institutional results and also present positive health outcomes to people with similar or different cultural backgrounds (Leininger, 2008). In order to understand the theory, a critique of its ideologies and concepts is important.Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Never use plagiarized sources. Get Your Original Essay on
Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay
Hire Professionals Just from $11/Page
Order Now Click here

Leininger’s theory is based on several terms that are addressed in the framework. The major ideas include care, caring, culture, culture care, and health concepts among others. Care has the aim of improving human condition based on their real or perceived needs. Caring is the activity or actions that are focused on care providence. Culture defines the values, norms, and beliefs that are either transmitted or shared among individuals or groups, which guide their way of living, actions, and decisions. Culture care includes multiple cultural aspects that influence the behavior of individuals or groups when encountering death, illness or human health conditions.

In theory, culture care diversity is defined as the acceptable differences in values and perceptions among different groups of people. The term cultural care universality is identified as similar meanings or common care features that are present in different cultures. Leininger presents nursing as the learned profession that is oriented towards care phenomenon. Finally, health is the state of well-being that is valued and demarcated by a selected culture (Leininger & McFarland, 1993).Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Firstly, care is assumed to be the essence of nursing, which is also dominant and distinct with a fusing focus.
The second assumption is that caring is necessary for health, healing, well-being or when facing death. The statement is different from the first claim, as it sees culture care as the wide field and also the rounded mean. It requires a nurse to perceive, explain, predict and understand nursing care with the purpose of directing care practices. In fact, the researcher assumes that caring is crucial to healing and curing with to the degree that curing cannot exist without caring.
The third assumption is that nursing is humanistic, scientific and transcultural care profession and discipline that has a central purpose to serve human beings around the world. However, culture care concepts, expressions and meanings are similar and at the same time different for the world cultures (Leininger & McFarland, 1993).Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay
The fourth assumption of a theory is that every human culture has its own practices and knowledge of care, and some of them vary between cultures. Thus, the theory assumes that cultural beliefs, practices and values are based on the context of a certain culture. In addition, the perceptions are rooted on kinship, spirituality, language, economics, politics, environment as well as technology.

The theory also assumes that culturally-based care that is satisfying, healthy and beneficial contributes not only to individuals’ welfare, but also to that of families and communities in the environmental context. Culturally competent care is only possible with proper knowledge of community, family and the patient’s values and expressions. Therefore, the differences and parallels in care are present in the human culture all over the world. In addition, lack of proper culturally congruent nursing approach results in such things as non-compliance, cultural conflicts, stress and other moral and ethical concerns. The last assumption is that qualitative paradigm presents new ways of understanding differences that can be used to discover ontological and epistemic dimensions of the human race (Leininger & McFarland, 1993).

The assumptions and the concepts show similarity. One of the major notable relationships between the concepts is the emphasis of culture, which is used to understand behavior. In addition, differences in culture and the influences on people’s lives are crucial for the theory. Moreover, the cultural competence is a necessary skill in successful nursing care.Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay  Furthermore, the theory emphasizes the importance of the insider’s and the outsider’s knowledge of culture; and how the latter ought to understand the former. Care is also seen as a crucial factor in the nursing practice especially when combined with understanding of culture. Care tends to have a certain power over nursing practice based on its emphasis all through the assumptions and the concepts (Leininger, 2008).

Origins of the Transcultural Nursing Care Theory
In order to further understand the theory, it is also important to look at its starting point and the inspirations of the theorist. The knowledge and experience of Leininger proves her competence in the area of nursing. Despite being born in a small town, Leininger’s background pushed her through the achievements, which contributed to her success in the career. She earned various honors and degrees including BS, BSN, MSN and PhD in nursing at different institutions in the US. During her career, Leininger developed an understanding of the importance of human care in nursing. She worked with patients from diverse cultural background, which influenced her perception of the differences that existed among patients based on their individual and cultural perceptions. Through constant observations and questioning of human care concepts, Leininger was able to establish the theory of cultural care.Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

The approach employed in the theory development is the sunrise model, which maps and presents the facts, components, dimensions and major theory’s concepts in order to have an integrated view of the different factors. The theory also uses the erthnonursing method, which qualitatively focuses on health, care and illness (Leininger & McFarland, 1993). The main theme, as observed earlier, is care and culture care, which is regarded as the core nursing principle.Usefulness of the Leininger’s Theory
Leininger’s theory is not only useful, but is also very popular in the nursing practice. Currently, nursing curricula accepts the theory and emphasizes on transcultural care and nursing. In addition, various researchers are regularly testing the theory, despite earlier beliefs that the theory was complex and hard for experimentation. The theory is applied to discover unknown care phenomena in various cultures. For example, the theory can be used to understand the type of care needed for a certain culture group (Fawcett & Desanto-Madeya, 2012).Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

An evaluation of Leininger’s theory to determine for testability shows that its lack of simplicity impairs the probability of testing. In fact, the theory is highly complex and takes a holistic perspective. The research methods are more qualitatively-oriented, and the scope is worldwide. Despite the difficulties with testing, Leininger’s theory has motivated various researches in the area. For example, the author also conducted a study on the Gadsup people in New Guniea using the ethnonursing framework. The research helped in identifying various values and beliefs specific to the people in regard to nursing. Moreover, the theory’s model was used by Wenger in 1991 to study the Old Order Amish. The research used the two models of Leininger’s theory discussed earlier and found that generic care, inclusive of anticipatory care is important in a community context (Leininger 2008).Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Client’s Review

“I have to say that when I first heard about this company I was like “are they for real”. I get in touch with them when I needed to write an essay… Here’s the thing, I would usually write it by myself but this time I actually needed help. I was desperate and the deadline was imminent. The result was amazing.”

Overall Evaluation of the Theory
An evaluation of Leininiger’s theory shows that the results are comprehensive, which has always hindered testability. However, the theory has led to other researches that utilized the models specific to Transcultural Nursing Care Theory. Despite the numerous benefits, Leininger’s theory has its weaknesses mostly because it emphasizes on culture and its comprehensive nature. In conclusion, its strengths include the aid for nurses on cultural competitiveness, focus on people, their environment, health and nursing care for different people. The abovementioned facts make the theory highly recognized in the industry. However, the theory fails to focus on symptoms and disease, which are largely important in nursing. The framework of the theory is static, which makes it fail to recognize the structural context, within which some health care issues stem (Fawcett, 2000).Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay


Critique of a Nursing Theory This is a critique of Myra Estrin Levine’s conservation principles model. I will be discussing the meaning of the theory of the four principles; conservation of energy, conservation of structural integrity, conservation of personal integrity, and conservation of social integrity. I will be using the criterion-based model (C-BaC) as a focus of the positive aspects of the theory, as outlined by Johnson & Webber (Johnson & Webber, 2010, p. 192-214). I will discuss the intent and theory, the concepts and propositions, and the usefulness in nursing practice. How a nurse is defined could be very influential for those who aspire to become a nurse Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay
Although I do not define optimal patient health as Levine would, I do believe that the boundaries of today’s health disciplines and Levine’s theory ultimately have the same patient goal; patient wholeness. The meaning of Levine’s conservation theory is defined differently in all the secondary sources used. There are no words used that are misunderstood. I would not constitute any of the definitions read as jargon, slang or unnecessary and meaningless writing. The primary source, Levine’s definition of “Conservation of Social Integrity is to recognize the individual as one who strives for recognition, respect, self awareness, selfhood and self determination” (Nursing Theories: A Companion to Nursing Theories and Models, 2010). Selfhood is one word that I am not familiar with and had to look up for confirmation of meaning. The meaning of selfhood is integrity; strive for selfhood would be to strive for individuality or for your own true identity. Concepts and Propositions Levine’s theories share four major concepts; person, environment, health, and nursing. A concept of person is one who is being holistic and striving to accomplish complete integrity, “someone who is future-oriented and past-aware” (“Myra Levine’s Conservation Theory“, 2009). Each individual has an internal and external environment that completes their wholeness. Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Theory Evaluation Paper – I chose Jean Watson theory of nursing. I work in a long term acute care hospital.
The purpose of this paper is to help you critically evaluate a nursing theory. This Assignment will be completed using the three stages of the theory evaluation process: Theory Description, Theory Analysis, and Theory Evaluation described in McEwen & Wills, p.97.
Please view the video below before submitting your paper. The video gives information on content and formatting of the Theory Evaluation Paper assignment. https://screencast-o-matic(dot)com/watch/cFQ0btqWOJ
Select one nursing theory (grand, middle range, practice theory) that best suits your area of practice. (Grand or middle-range may provide more information)
Discuss your rationale for selecting that theory over the other nursing theories (Introduction paragraph)
Use Chinn and Kramer (2005) components of Theory Description: (Located in McEwen & Wills, pg. 101-102 and Table 5-3)
Purpose (Descriptive, Explanatory, Predictive, Prescriptive; Include scope- grand, middle-range, practice)Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay
Concepts (Introduce and list concepts)
Definitions (of concepts and other important aspects)
Relationship (among concepts)
Structure (Is there a diagram to give clarity of structure)
Assumptions (beliefs, propositions)
Use Fawcett (2005) criteria for Theory Analysis: (Located in McEwin & Wills, pg.100-101)
Theory’s Origin (historical creation and evolution of theory)
Unique Focus (distinctive views)
Content (include definitions of metaparadigm concepts of person, environment, health, nursing)
Use Fawcett (2005) criteria for Theory Evaluation: (Located in McEwin & Wills, pg. 100-101)
Significance (usefulness, social significance, cultural significance)
Comprehensiveness of the content (thoroughness, utility)
Logical Congruence (consistency & Clarity of theory; consistent use of concepts)
Credibility (legitimacy, empirical support through research)
Contribution to Nursing (usefulness to nursing practice, education, and research)
Concluding statements summarize the content. (Conclusion paragraph)
Paper should be 4-5 pages in length, excluding the title and references pages.
Please be sure to support your paper using at least 5 peer-reviewed resources. (APA in-text citations and APA Reference page)
Additional Instructions: Your assignment should be typed into a Word or other word processing document, formatted in APA style. The assignments must include Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Introduction paragraph to explain why this theory was chosen for your area of nursing (Do not use first person)
Suggestion to use Level 1 headings for the three stages and conclusion sections: Theory Description, Theory Analysis, and Theory Evaluation and Conclusion
Suggestion to use Level 2 headings for content requested above and lettered underneath each stage: Purpose, Concepts, Definitions, etc.
A references page (APA)
Rubric Detail
A rubric lists grading criteria that instructors use to evaluate student work. Your instructor linked a rubric to this item and made it available to you. Select Grid View or List View to change the rubric’s layout.
Name: Theory Evaluation Paper
Description: Introduction to topic paper. This assignment requires proper APA format. This includes a title page, reference page, and proper headings. An abstract is not required. Write a 4-5-page paper (not including title page and reference page) addressing the following: 1. Select one nursing theory (grand, middle range theory) that best suits your area of practice. 2. Discuss your rationale for selecting that theory over the other nursing theories. Use listed criteria to organize your paper and include at least 5 references. Nursing Theory Critique Paper Example Essay

Get your Plagiarism-free essays from

Open chat
Lets chat on via WhatsApp
Hello, Welcome to our WhatsApp support. Reply to this message to start a chat.